AutoAnything vs. Buy Auto Parts vs. JC Whitney: Top Auto Part Sites Reviewed and Compared

Education
When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission

AutoAnything vs. Buy Auto Parts vs. JC Whitney: Top Auto Part Sites Reviewed and Compared

Updated September 9, 2014
5 minute read
Dive deeper into brands mentioned in this guide

AutoAnything

AutoAnything was founded in 1979 by Selwyn Klein, who began the business selling sheepskin seat covers and floor mats. In 1997, he was joined by his son and they expanded the business selling auto parts online. Today, they are one of the largest online retailers of specialized auto parts.

AutoAnything Auto Parts

AutoAnything sells auto parts for all vehicles including RVs, motorcycles, boats and ATV. The auto parts they carry are all name brand products including:

  • Coverking
  • WeatherTech
  • Husky Liners
  • Powerstop
  • Tonno Pro
  • BAK
  • K&N
  • AVS
  • CalTrend
  • Magnaflow

You can search for auto parts by make, model and year of vehicle, by brand or by going to one of their auto part categories:

  • Performance Parts
  • Exterior Accessories
  • Interior Accessories
  • Other Accessories such as motorcycles, ATV, pet travel, mobile electronics and tail gating.
  • Today’s Deals

AutoAnything Features

AutoAnything has the following benefits for their auto part customers.

  • They have live chat every day during business hours.
  • AutoAnything offers free shipping within the contiguous United States on more than 99% of their products with no minimum purchase requirements.
  • AutoAnything has a low price guarantee that states they will beat any online or offline price up to 1 year from the date of purchase.
  • They will accept returns for most products within 30 days of receipt of the product.
  • Customers can call their in-house auto part experts to help you choose which auto part you need.
  • They have specials listed on their website. They are currently offering free overnight FedEx shipping with K&N air filters.

AutoAnything Coupons

AutoAnything Customer Satisfaction

AutoAnything is an accredited member of the San Diego Better Business Bureau with an A+ rating. They are a Google Trusted Store with a rating of 4.7 out of 5. AutoAnything is also customer certified with Bizrate.com with the following ratings:

  • Overall satisfaction of 8.8 out of 10
  • Would shop here again: 8.8/10
  • Likelihood to recommend: 9.0/10
  • Satisfaction with checkout: 9.4/10
  • Prices relative to other online retailers: 8.9/10
  • Product selection: 9.0/10
  • Shipping charges: 9.4/10
  • On-time delivery: 8.9/10
  • Product availability: 9.2/10
  • Customer support: 8.8/10
  • Returns process: 10/10

Buy Auto Parts

Buy Auto Parts was formed in 1987 and went online in 2001 with their auto parts website. They are located in San Diego, California and one of the largest distributors of auto parts worldwide.

Buy Auto Parts Product Line

Buy Auto Parts has a large selection of OEM replacement parts for car and trucks which you can search for by make and model, year, search engine or inventory categories. Their featured products include:

  • AC Compressors
  • Turbocharger
  • Strut Assembly
  • Power Steering Rack
  • Fuel Pump Assembly
  • Control Arm
  • Fuel Injector
  • Performance Parts

They keep a defective history for all of the parts they sell that you can ask for. Buy Auto Parts sells all major brands of auto parts and performance parts including:

  • SmittyBilt
  • aFe Power
  • Borg Warner Turbo Systems
  • Magnaflow
  • Yukon Gear and Axle
  • Bilstein
  • USA Standard Gear
  • AC Delco
  • Bosch
  • Exedy

Buy Auto Parts Features

Buy Auto Parts has the following customer advantages:

  • Buy Auto Parts offers free UPS ground shipping with all orders over $50 within the continental United States.
  • They have American customer support.
  • Their warranty covers parts and shipping.
  • Buy Auto Parts also includes how-to videos and articles plus an auto parts buyer’s guide.

Buy Auto Parts Coupons

Buy Auto Parts Customer Satisfaction

Buy Auto Parts is an accredited member of the San Diego Better Business Bureau with an A+ rating. They are also a Google Trusted Store member, Authorize.Net merchant and an Elite member of ResellerRatings.com with a rating of 9.58 out of 10 and the following comments:

  • "Amazing customer service, easy to work with, and quick delivery. What else could you ask for??? Oh, the price.....unbeatable."
  • "They have an excellent customer service dept!! We had issue with ordering the wrong part. They had no problems helping me locate the new parts and shipping them out. Even including a return label for the parts I had ordered wrong!! Thank you so much!! We will surely be ordering from you guys again!! "
  • "Both Stuart and Felipe were awesome to work with. Shipping was extremely fast. I ordered the part but found out it was not needed before I installed it. The return was easy and they were very helpful and friendly."

JC Whitney

JC Whitney has been in the auto parts business for almost 100 years. They were founded in 1915 by Israel Warshawsky when he opened the Warshawsky Company in Chicago. After WWII, the JC Whitney catalog became common among anyone who worked on cars and do-it-yourselfers.

JC Whitney Auto Parts

JC Whitney sells auto parts for all vehicles including cars, trucks, RV, ATV, UTV and motorcycles. You can search for auto parts by make, model and year, search engine or by going to one of their categories.

Their website makes it easy to find the exact auto parts you are looking for. You can also browse through the following main categories:

JC Whitney carries all major brands of auto parts including:

  • JVC
  • K&N
  • Covercraft
  • Lund
  • Garage-Pro
  • WeatherTech
  • Curt
  • Bestop

JC Whitney Features

JC Whitney gives their customers the following advantages:

  • JC Whitney offers free standard shipping on most of their products without a minimum purchase requirement within the continental United States.
  • They have live chat during business hours.
  • JC Whitney accepts returns within 30 days of receipt.
  • They offer a 100% satisfaction guarantee.
  • You can order one of the print catalogues for motorcycle, truck, jeep or general auto parts.
  • They have a price match guarantee that states they will refund the difference if you find an identical product at a lower price.

JC Whitney Customer Satisfaction

JC Whitney is an accredited member of the Chicago Better Business Bureau with an A+ rating. They are rated 7.90 out of a possible 10 on ResellerRatings.com with the following comments:

  • "The delivery was on time and the price was cheaper than any other place in my area"
  • "I couldn't find the "sub-model" for my vehicle and had a chat with someone and gave them the VIN for my vehicle and they e-mailed me back with the information that I needed to complete my order which I received in less time than expected."
  • "Website is easy to use. Ordering simple, along with payment. Delivery rates reasonable. Item delivered in a reasonable amount of time as expected."

Auto Part Sites Conclusion

These auto part stores are all similar in that they all carry a large selection of brand name auto parts for all types of vehicles. You can call auto parts experts at AutoAnything and get advice on which products to buy. JC Whitney has their auto parts listed in many categories to make them easier to find on their website and Buy Auto Parts has a section of how-to articles and videos and buyer guides on their online store.